+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 30 of 52
Thread: Hogan/Dunnigan/Tiger
-
03-05-2006 06:20 PM #1
- Join Date
- Feb 2004
- Posts
- 4,163
Hogan/Dunnigan/Tiger
A couple of pics for a forum member who is interested in seeing what ON PLANE means.
Source:
"The Secret to the Golf Swing" by John Dunnigan.
www.golfbetterproductions.com
The Hogan pic did not attach.
-
03-06-2006 03:16 PM #2
The hands should touch the shaft axes plane where on the downswing?
Strive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-06-2006 03:18 PM #3
I would love to see Tiger or any other tour pro’s single plane downswing motion in every position. I just can’t find one.
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-06-2006 07:02 PM #4
- Join Date
- Feb 2004
- Posts
- 4,163
Originally Posted by mberube
If the hands are on the turned shoulder plane at the top, they will gradually move down to the shaft axis plane by the time they are at or just below hip height and the reference point is when the shaft coincides with the right forearm. This is called a plane shift and most, if not all, good players make one. It is obvious in the shots of Dunnigan above and you can see that Tiger is shifting his hands from the TSP back down towards the SAP. His "new" swing brings the shaft almost coinciding with the right forearm, SAP(Pg 98, "Tiger's New Swing," Hank Haney, second pic). If he was to be on perfect plane, he would not block the ball, but where does he miss most of his drives, if he does? Right or left?
The other truth is that one can create any plane reference point they want and describe the movements in terms of that plane. Draw a line from the ball to the golfer's nose and then describe the movement of the hands or whatever relative to that line. The two that are mentioned are the ones that are referred to the most.
Check the positions of Hogan, Moe Norman, & George Knudson, three of the greatest ball strikers, ever, relative to the two planes I mentioned. If they vary from the above, I will eat my divot. Tiger is NOT a great ball striker. His drives miss far too many fairways for him to be classified that way. Sure, he was #1 in GIR's this weekend, but how long was the Doral rough?" The only reason he won was because he was 58/58 in putts from 6' and in. He is probably the greatest putter ever.
Regardless of any of the above, golfers can still play good golf, even if they return the club back down along the turned shoulder plane. Just learn how to block the shot with your hands and/or your body. But, is it not easier to learn to do something correctly in the first place, than to learn to do something else correctly to compensate for something you have learned to do that is not ideal? If one has had some success with the latter, then doubting the former is understandable. I still recommend Mark Evershed's "Knowledge Video," and anything TGM ("The Golfing Machine.") With the proper knowledge and understanding, it is easier to decide where to go to get on the path to improvement. There is nothing wrong in perfecting ones faults; it just makes it tougher to get better.
-
03-07-2006 08:42 AM #5
Don’t get me wrong Lyle, I do believe its the right way to swing. I’m just searching for a model swinger. I like to analyse the golf swing and then make myself some kind of training tool to force my swing on the desired swing path.
I was an OTT swinger 5 years ago and fixed it by creating a home made “inside approach” before it even existed. On TV that is.
When I figure out exactly what I want to do I will post pictures. The only way that I can make this tool is to find the ideal swing motion sequence.
If you have rear view pics of every downswing frames from a pro, I would love to see them.
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-07-2006 09:39 AM #6
- Join Date
- Apr 2004
- Location
- K
- Posts
- 791
Here are some pics of the OPS poster child.
Back at it.
-
03-07-2006 09:54 AM #7
He is very steep on his back swing and then reroutes it. I’m missing a frame from the top to waist high.
Do you or anybody have a video session of him or any other pro that has a single plane?
I know, I know I’m asking a lot but some of you golf freaks must have it.
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-07-2006 07:24 PM #8
- Join Date
- Feb 2004
- Posts
- 4,163
Originally Posted by mberube
At the top, pic 4, his hands are on the TSP and the left arm coincides with the shoulder turn. Classic "ONE PLANE." Also, in pic 4 I have included the SAP line I made in pic one to show that his right elbow is ON or just below this line, which is even better.
The most important shot is pic 5. His hands move back and down so that they are ON the SAP, AND the club shaft coincides with this, AND covers the right forearm. My plane line covers this but is visible if you check "Started's" original attachment.
The only way that he can get to this position is to have a plane shift, or as you say, "reroutes it." This rerouting is NOT, however, a LOOP. It is just Chad pushing his hands back towards the camera FIRST, instead of moving them towards the ball. While the difference between the TSP and the SAP in Chad's swing is relatively small, compared to some, it still shows what Evershed, TGM, Dunnigan, & O'Grady teach. The arms/hands move to an on, shaft axis plane, position.
-
03-07-2006 08:12 PM #9
- Join Date
- Apr 2004
- Location
- K
- Posts
- 791
Here is something to compare to Tiger 2002 mid-iron (with BC's lines). BC might want to comment on it.
Back at it.
-
03-08-2006 08:32 AM #10
- Join Date
- Feb 2004
- Posts
- 4,163
Originally Posted by Started2k3
In "Tiger's New Swing," it is obvious that he has flattened the downswing plane, but whether he gets to the shaft axis plane, I don't know. I would love to see a sequence similar to the above of his current action.
This may or may not be relevant, but Tiger hits his shots with a fade so his setup is more open, making the downswing plane a little more "upright", ie., more likely to be above the shaft axis plane. Secondly, most of Tiger's misses go right indicating that he blocks most of his shots. A lower body that is too far around or ahead of the upper, pulls the arms more outwardly, which again would make his downswing steeper. Having said this, the idea of returning closer to the shaft axis plane on the downswing, will make any golfer lacking Tour calibre talent to compensate, a better ball striker.
Because Tiger is the best "player" in the world, does NOT make him the best ball striker, and his swing is NOT one that I would use if I was looking for one to have golfers copy. The best ball strikers could hit fairways. Tiger's prowess is putting. He is probably the best ever and this is why he wins. His length does not hurt either even though he is in the rough a bit less than half the time.
Where do you get these sequences? They are great.
-
03-08-2006 09:02 AM #11
Here are some swing sequence but they are old.
http://asafgolf.free.fr/swings/swings.htmStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-08-2006 11:21 AM #12
- Join Date
- Apr 2004
- Location
- K
- Posts
- 791
Originally Posted by BC MIST
This guys site used to be freely available (no password required). I just emailed the guy and he sent me the password (no strings ... so far).
There are quite a few tour swings (pics and vids).
The pictures can't be saved directly, but with a little bit of clever computering you can capture the picture (PM me if you want to know what I do).Back at it.
-
03-10-2006 08:58 AM #13
Password: bluegoat
Strive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-10-2006 01:43 PM #14
- Join Date
- Apr 2004
- Location
- K
- Posts
- 791
Originally Posted by mberube
Now if he shuts his site down, I will be pissed.
BTW - my password to my account on this site is: ########
What is yours?
Trust me you can tell me. I won't tell any one.Back at it.
-
03-10-2006 01:46 PM #15
- Join Date
- Feb 2004
- Posts
- 4,163
Originally Posted by Started2k3
Please keep this to yourself.
-
03-10-2006 02:11 PM #16
I extracted a few of pics (Howell III, Sergio, VJ, Me and me) and drew a couple of lines. All three players have their hands touching the SAP at hip high as illustrated with the circle.
Compared to my swing, I need to bring back my hands to the SAP. That will probably align my saft to the SAP at impact. Hmmmm!! Lots of work to do all though I’m not in a bas position. Comments?
Got to make a tool to force me in that position.
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-11-2006 01:44 PM #17
Wow! this is all great stuff guys. Looks like you have a super place to practice mberube. There is nowhere in my house I can swing without hitting something.
-
03-11-2006 05:40 PM #18
- Join Date
- Feb 2004
- Posts
- 4,163
Originally Posted by mberube
The first is how "FLAT" or how "LAID OFF" or how much BEHIND their bums, the shaft is as the downswing starts. Some, "old fashioned" instructors would see this as a fault, stating that the club head is coming into the ball "too much from the inside." I have played a long time and I have NEVER seen anyone swing too much from the inside. 98% of golfers swing too much from ABOVE plane and/or from the outside. The truth is that this flattening motion should be perceived as essential to achieving consistency.
The second is the position of VJ's right hand in pic 7. Except for his finger tips, his right hand is completely off the club. How can a guy become #1 in the world doing that? The morons at Golf Digest actually wrote an article about this position calling it, I believe, "the new release." Try it and you while you may break a few windows, you won't break 150.
Mike, I work on the motion of moving my hands BACK toward the camera each time I practice, by doing two things: (1) I use John Dunnigan's "Flattening drill," which he describes here - http://www.golfbetterproductions.com....asp?drillID=3. (2) I lay a 2' to 3' piece of masking tape on the mat coming into the ball at about a 30* angle. As I swing down I can "SEE/FEEL" my hands and arms staying on my side of the this tape, AND, I can see the clubhead coming into the ball and beyond at this same angle. The ironic thing is that while I see the underneath drop of the arms/hands and the inside path of the club head, I also "FEEL" my hands arms coming very sharply low and left through impact. Watching the good players in slow mo, this is exactly what they do. The hands are going left while the club head is going right. This may sound confusing, but it works. The tape on the mat works well for me, but if you come up with a device to help get your hands back down to the shaft plane, would you let us have a peek?
For we mortals, I believe this plane shift is "The Secret to the Golf Swing," and yet, how many golfers understand this?
-
03-11-2006 09:55 PM #19Originally Posted by little brit
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-11-2006 10:33 PM #20Originally Posted by BC MIST
Let me tell you that it feels great. I’m hitting it a bit thin but that is normal for now. Remarkably this swing change added 4 mph to my swing speed on an 8 iron. I don’t know what it looks like on video but I will tell you in two week.
As for the tape drill that you use, It doesn’t work for me. I get stuck. I feel like my arms separate from my body at and post impact. It will probably work better when my swing comes down closer or on the SAP.
When I figure out what device I need to fabricate, I will be happy to share it with a video session print screen at the same time.
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-12-2006 08:22 AM #21
- Join Date
- Feb 2004
- Posts
- 4,163
Originally Posted by mberube
One of the best "solutions" of this blocking move is to have the upper left arm stay in contact with the left upper chest, connection, through the entire downswing. It is one of the 4 important pressure points that TGM describes. You use of the right index finger as a pressure point is one of the others.
It would have been interesting to see a shot of your swing, from directly behind you, a little after impact, just to see if and how much separation you actually may have had.
What is also good about what you are doing is that you are finding your own way to improvement vesus relying on some instructor, or tips, or whatever. Good golf teachers teach the golfer to teach themselves. How many do that?
-
03-13-2006 10:45 AM #22One of the best "solutions" of this blocking move is to have the upper left arm stay in contact with the left upper chest, connection, through the entire downswing. It is one of the 4 important pressure points that TGM describes. You use of the right index finger as a pressure point is one of the others.
What are the other 2 pressure points?
Is thhis what you want or a video session with the camera in my back?
MikeLast edited by mberube; 03-13-2006 at 10:59 AM.
Strive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-13-2006 10:46 AM #23
Part 2
Strive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-13-2006 11:32 AM #24
- Join Date
- Apr 2004
- Location
- K
- Posts
- 791
mberube,
Those stills are pretty cool. I was looking at the ball's impact on the sheet - definately in to out club head path.
What I would do if I could ever convince my wife to let me have your setup:
Mark the target line with masking tape on the sheet (maybe with a couple of parallel lines to either side 4-5 inches). This would give me a clear indication of how much the swing was in-out.Back at it.
-
03-13-2006 11:51 AM #25Originally Posted by Started2k3
My golf simulator tells me exactly what I did wrong: swing path, ball flight. The swing you see here is in-to-out 6 degrees, 1 degree closed clubface at impact resulting in a right to left ball flight with the ball landing 7 yards left of target.
All my golf buddies envy my setup. It’s very cool. I just got the simulator a month ago. It’s a must buy when you hit in a net. At least I now know where the ball is going and not practicing a hook every day and not knowing it. The downside is that I can’t swing a driver, yet, 8I is the safest club and that I lose all my heat cause the garage is not well insulated. It makes it hard/impossible to swing during cold winter evenings. I’ll fix it up for next winter.
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-17-2006 07:50 AM #26
- Join Date
- Feb 2005
- Posts
- 395
Originally Posted by mberube
pp2: right palm on the aft side of shaft
pp3: right index pressure on side of shaft
pp4: wherever left arm touches chest.
i dont have the book with me right now, but im pretty sure tahts it.
-
03-17-2006 09:03 AM #27Originally Posted by Powerdraw
I do the “towel under arm” drill but I never now exactly where to put the towel. Is it in the middle of the bicep under the pectoral or directly under the armpit?
MikeStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-17-2006 09:30 AM #28
- Join Date
- Feb 2005
- Posts
- 395
this is not a towel drill thing. Actually i think it is counter-productive and unpowerfull....i know i know, if VJ does it then...BS. hes just that damn good to get away with it, but remember he did bust a rib cuz of it.
PP4 is once the left arm has been thrown across chest at top of swing via a pivot motion or otherwise, the left arm touches the left titty. From here, via the pivot, the left arm will get blasted off the chest as a power source wich is exactly the opposite of the towel drill. imagine left arm as a rope, you turn back to get rope across chest and you try and blast it off through impact without using your left arm, imagine you have slepped on your left arm and it feels numb and from there you try to fling the numb left arm across chest and blast it off your chest at followthrough...a form of lag i guess. hope this helps.
-
03-17-2006 09:48 AM #29Originally Posted by PowerdrawStrive for perfection, but never expect it!
-
03-17-2006 12:42 PM #30
- Join Date
- Apr 2004
- Location
- K
- Posts
- 791
Originally Posted by PowerdrawBack at it.
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Similar Threads
-
Ben Hogan CS3 driver & New 56,60* Ben Hogan Riviera wedges
By Wedgies in forum Left Hand ClubsReplies: 2Last Post: 10-19-2009, 11:08 AM -
Ben Hogan Staff Golf Bag with Bonus Hogan umbrella
By junkhouse in forum Other Golf AdsReplies: 7Last Post: 09-10-2009, 08:04 AM -
FS Hogan apex plus irons and hogan carry bag.
By knickers in forum Right Hand SetsReplies: 12Last Post: 09-28-2008, 04:28 AM -
Hogan FTX
By chipandput in forum Right Hand SetsReplies: 3Last Post: 06-06-2006, 07:53 PM -
Ben Hogan C-S3
By Gopherhomes in forum Right Hand SetsReplies: 1Last Post: 07-06-2005, 04:48 PM