+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 20 of 20
Thread: 3 iron vs. 5 wood?
-
05-15-2007 08:25 AM #1
- Join Date
- Jun 2004
- Location
- Ottawa
- Posts
- 780
3 iron vs. 5 wood?
I would like to know when to would you play a 3 iron vs. 5 wood? I hit both fairly the same distance with my 5, I am more accurate. So my 3 always sits on the bench most of the time.
I hit the woods quite high so I would like to think that 3 iron would stay in a lower trajectory? Whats the norm or your experience?
-
05-15-2007 08:52 AM #2
3 iron has lower trajectory and more roll. It is also a more difficult club to hit. Depending on the loft of your clubs though you might not be comparing apples with apples as most 5 woods have 18-19 degrees of loft while 3 irons have on average 21-22 loft. I would also tend to believe that a 5 wood has a higher MOI than an iron and is much easier to hit because of the tip section(.335 tip)
Live as if you were to die tomorrow. Learn as if you were to live forever.
Mahatma Gandhi
-
05-15-2007 09:25 AM #3
- Join Date
- Mar 2005
- Location
- XXXXXXXXXXXX
- Posts
- 4,215
I now use my 3 iron for whacking out dandelions in the back yard
Seriously though, if you hit your 3 iron and 5 wood the same distance, yet hit the 5 wood with more accuracy I think you have answered your own question. Why bother with the 3 iron if that 5 wood is golden?
My opinions are my own, I do not follow others.
-
05-15-2007 11:08 AM #4
- Join Date
- Jun 2004
- Location
- Ottawa
- Posts
- 780
Thanks... so lower trajectory and more roll? anything else as to why one vs the other...
-
05-15-2007 11:25 AM #5
generally, a 5 wood should travel further and be easier to hit, but not for everyone obviously. Consider taking out the 3 iron and adding a hybrid. What you should look to do is fill any yardage gaps. If you hit them both the same, take one out and maybe add a wedge. Or, depending on the course and conditions you may want to favour one over the other based on the ball flight.
I got a fever. And the only prescription is more golf equipment.
-
05-15-2007 04:43 PM #6
Jeffc. I personally prefer a fairway wood over a hybrid. First off a wood shaft is softer in the tip section. Secondly the head has more volume than a hybrid and they don't sound as clunky. But that's just me.
Live as if you were to die tomorrow. Learn as if you were to live forever.
Mahatma Gandhi
-
05-15-2007 04:58 PM #7
Also worth mentioning is that that some hybrids take wood shafts.
Specifically, both of the Wishon hybrids (785 and 321) use wood shafts. I have the 785s and they get the ball up in the air very quickly.
-
05-15-2007 05:29 PM #8
- Join Date
- Oct 2006
- Location
- Ottawa
- Posts
- 89
I switched my 3 iron (2nd generation PING - Karsten II) for a Callaway Steelhead Plus 7-wood almost 7 years ago and found my accuracy increased tremendously and so did my handicap. It is easier to glide a fairway wood in non perfect lies than a 3 iron. The iron is more subject to twist either closed or open depending on the lie.
I have now switched my 7-wood for a 21 deg. PING Rapture hybrid and I wonder why I did not switch earlier. As some of the pros state in ads for hybrids, this is almost like cheating. I just added last week a second PING Rapture hybrid (24 deg.)in my bag to replace my my 4 High Launch G2 iron. In my case the results speak for themselves. My handicap is already starting to get back to normal.
Also to note is that you can fit whatever shaft you desire in those clubs. I got a professional fitting session last fall and was recommended a particular type of shaft for my swing and adopted the same recommended make of shaft in my driver, 5-wood, and two hybrids.Keep it vertical!!
-
05-15-2007 06:22 PM #9
All that matters here is what the difference is for you. While the Chief is probably right, and the 3 iron should theoretically go lower with more roll, its not always the case. My 3 iron goes extremely high, with no roll, and my 5 wood goes lower, with more roll As Golfbum said, you have already answered your own question. You hit the 5 more accurately, and the same distance as the 3. You should be using the five. There is no point in having two clubs that go the same distance.
I started using a 2 iron last year, and was hitting it the same distance as my 5 wood, so I dropped the 5 and replaced it with a 4 wood (I don't carry a 3 wood), and that nicely fills the gap between the driver and the 2 iron. The bottom line is, it's all about finding the combo that works for you. Also, remember this. Though theoretical knowledge is great, I have learned on this forum that the theoretical really doesn't matter much of the time, because it often doesn't match the actual results. So, don't go by what people say your clubs "should" do....go by what they actually do.
-
05-15-2007 07:15 PM #10
Of course I am right Jonf all kidding aside one has to be careful when comparing clubs. Some 5 woods have 19 degree of loft while some others have 21-22. Some strong 3 irons have 19 degrees of loft while some others are off specs. A nice logical set up would be 15-18-21-24 in hybrids or fairway woods. 21 and 24 fw replace 3 and 4 iron. Jonf I sure would like to see your swing and measure the actual lofts on your clubs. Vancouver is a little far though
Live as if you were to die tomorrow. Learn as if you were to live forever.
Mahatma Gandhi
-
05-15-2007 07:24 PM #11
-
05-15-2007 07:26 PM #12
-
05-15-2007 08:56 PM #13Also worth mentioning is that that some hybrids take wood shafts.Live as if you were to die tomorrow. Learn as if you were to live forever.
Mahatma Gandhi
-
05-15-2007 09:03 PM #14
I tried that experiment once but couldn't get a shaft that worked.
-
05-15-2007 09:14 PM #15
I would think generally a 5w is considered less stable in the wind but a safer bet if you need the carry. Most (even pros) probably land it softer as well.
-
05-15-2007 09:32 PM #16
- Join Date
- Jun 2004
- Location
- Ottawa
- Posts
- 780
Thanks for the feedback.... I guess, my 3 lost the battle....I would never take out my 5w as it's the most reliable club in my bag.
As per being high, I hit all my irons, woods and driver 8.5 quite high and yes on windy days I take a hit.
I am quite happy with all my irons with the exception of the 3 which I was not sure what to do with it. Not reliable to me as something I was hitting good and some times bad, when it was good it was equal to my 5w so I guess it’ out.
Thanks guys!
-
05-15-2007 09:33 PM #17
-
05-15-2007 09:39 PM #18
I'm pretty sure I tried it with a BiMatrx shaft. I can't remember what trim, if any I used.
I've got ProjectX wood shafts in my hybrids now and I quite like them so I'm guessing that the BiMatrx was too light.
-
06-11-2007 09:02 AM #19
Try a hybrid it could change your long game like it did mine. I'm with golfbum though if you hit a 5wood clean mos tof the time who cares about another club that distance. You already got your high % shot.
-
06-13-2007 06:28 AM #20
- Join Date
- Oct 2002
- Posts
- 142
Retire the 3 iron...get another wedge...fill the yardage gaps...better short game...more one putts...score goes down...
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Similar Threads
-
NICKENT 3 WOOD or 3DX DC 2 IRON
By MixBag in forum Right Hand WoodsReplies: 3Last Post: 05-19-2008, 06:08 PM -
Bazooka Iron-/wood
By bazooka Don in forum Right Hand WoodsReplies: 3Last Post: 07-25-2006, 03:35 PM -
FS: Ping Eye 2 iron and wood set
By daveyc in forum Right Hand SetsReplies: 2Last Post: 07-16-2006, 01:38 PM -
52 or 60 and 5 wood or 2 iron
By beefstuf in forum General Golf TalkReplies: 19Last Post: 07-06-2005, 11:31 PM -
Bazooka J Max Iron Wood
By doglezard in forum Right Hand SetsReplies: 1Last Post: 10-23-2004, 07:30 AM