Printable View
Let's say that I'm playing in a tournament and distance measuring devices are allowed (distance measuring only, NOT slope, temperature etc.). If I am so inclined, am I allowed to share the readings with my FCs??
Would providing distance information be considered giving advice under 8-1?
yes you are
You are allowed to share distance information.
Can I charge $$ for said information?? :scratchchQuote:
Originally Posted by jvincent
It won't win you any friends, but I don't see why not.
;)Quote:
Originally Posted by jvincent
But you can't ask them for it or do they have to offer?
I can see it now...Quote:
Originally Posted by Hacker
Indio: Now where to hell are the markers on this hole?
Hacker: Hey buddy, gimmie $10 and I will tell you how far it is to the pin....
Indio: Hey Hacker..... Go &?%&?% %&??%%
Hacker: As you wish Mon ami... :-)
I'm shocked :rolleyes :rolleyesQuote:
Originally Posted by Indio
For you I would extend my "Good Friend Discount".....................$9.50
I guess I will find out at 9:15 tomorrow :-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Hacker
Here's a free tip.........the first hole is straight away, green slightly elevated
I'm pretty sure you can ask since it falls under the "information" category.Quote:
Originally Posted by LBH
From a rules perspective it's no different that asking how long a hole is, etc.
There is nothing in the rules to stop you asking. It's upto your FC whetter he tells you. :confusedQuote:
Originally Posted by LBH
ok so you can ask how far is the hole but you can't ask which club he used right? if someone asks, and the FC answers, who is the penalty on?
Correct, you can't ask the club.
If you ask, you get a penalty. If he answers then he also gets a penalty.
You can after both of you have played.Quote:
Originally Posted by sillywilly
Both players are penalized 8-1(a)(b)
ok, if i'm on a par 3 and its 130 yards away... and after i hit my shot and come up short i yell out #@$# i knew I should have used my nine... is that the same thing? obviously i just told everyone i used a pw
8-1/8 Comment About Club Selection After Stroke http://www.usga.org/playing/rules/bo...es/blueDot.gif
Q. After playing a stroke, a player says: “I should have used a 5-iron.” Was the player in breach of Rule 8-1?
A. If the statement was made casually, there was no breach. If the statement was made to another player who had a shot to play from about the same position, there was a breach.
what if it was made to no one in particular, just talking to him self loud enough that others could hear... who still had to take their shot from the same spot
I believe AAA just answered that.
i suppose i should re-word my last post. He yells it our after coming up short. Yells it to himself or the golf gods. The 3 players still to play get all the info they need. this is no different than saying "hey guys... this is the club i used"
just because he didn't do it on purpose of with the intention of helping them out doesn't mean he didn't do it. why in this case do they look at your intention before seeing if you should be penalized? any other rules like that?
The RCGA says giving yardage is sharing info that would obtained in books(yardage) sprinkler heads etc. & not giving advice. Be nice to your fellow players.RadarQuote:
Originally Posted by Hacker
I can see your point sillywilly. There are lots of things that may happen that we didn't intend on, but we still get penalized. Why is this one different?Quote:
Originally Posted by sillywilly
How about this scenario. First golfer teeing off on a dog leg. Decides to hit his driver. Drives it through the fairway into the far trees of the dogleg. Says casually, "Guess I shouldn't have hit the driver". The remaining three golfers, all leaning on their drivers return to their bag to grab the 3-wood.
Penalty?
He did say it casually without intent to give the others information about what club he was swinging (as if they couldn't tell it was the driver).
I know that this scenario is covered in the decisions, I'm just too lazy to search for it right now.