If you had to chose which one you felt more comfortable on, which would you chose?
... and since everyone has a different range of shots, let's do it by club instead of yardage:
Would you rather be standing on the tee box holding a wedge or a 5 iron? :book
Personally I think I'd rather the 5 iron shot... as Shushu mentioned in another thread, those 90-100 yard par threes scare the bajesus out of me!